Unlike everyone else in the Django world, I have not written a blog application.
Instead I want to use your blog application. Definitely for my upcoming blog transfer to my own personal site (Blogger's limitations annoy me), and possibly for use in NASA Science Mission Directorate Spacebook project. So what am I looking for in your blog?
In no particular order these are the must-haves:
- Elegant user interface.
- Follows Django/Python best practices.
- Easy to integrate into another application (which should be the case if you followed the above point).
- Code highlighting via pygments.
- Relies on JQuery for JavaScript, and degrades properly.
- Publishes legal RSS feeds.
- Allows for use of several input formats (Restructured Text, Markdown, etc)
- Hooks for integrating WYSIWYG editor
- Allows for multiple users each with their own blog.
- Renders humanely in FF, Safari, and IE 6, 7, and 8.
- Any sort of decent documentation.
- Publishes ATOM feeds.
- Allows for multiple users on a particular blog.
- Already has a WYSIWYG editor.
- Handy import/export functions that follow whatever standards Blogger might have.
- I have my own server space. Plus, NASA has its own servers. So Google App Engine compliant blog systems need to also support the standard Django ORM.
- I am doing this in Django/Pinax/Python/PostGreSql on Linux. Systems that do not play well there need not apply.
Well, as much as I am a fan of Pinax, the default blog application doesn't do everything we want it to do for Spacebook. So your application might become the blog engine used by us. And when we launch, we'll be sharing credit with anyone who contributed from the open source community to our efforts.
Edit on August 26th, 2010: I solved how to do this research by co-authoring Django Packages which gives us this handy reference. Also, at this point in time, as part of larger systems, I've written several blog systems for clients.
27 comments:
NASA Ames is looking at django and I'm working with some people at JPL who might be interested in django.
I'll be curious to hear how it goes for your projects.
-kurt
http://schwehr.org
You should definetely check Byteflow http://byteflow.su/ . It has impressive number of features and very clean codebase. Actually I am going to use it for my personal blog.
You should definetely check Byteflow http://byteflow.su/ . It has impressive number of features and very clean codebase. Actually I am going to use it for my personal blog.
hostable on GAE would be a + ? :)
Can you give some of the background/justification for the requirement of legal RSS feeds and Atom as only an optional thing. There are so many RSS specs that being merely spec-compliant doesn't guarantee much and they're all broken in interesting and annoying ways, whereas Atom was designed (and did) fix the technical problems, why not join us here in the 21st century and use Atom?
Well ... the one thing missing from belleville is documentation, but that wouldn't take me long to update.
@kurt: I would love to talk with you guys! I wonder if there is a NASA Django mailing list. On Spacebook we will be able to create that easily enough, and within the NASA domain.
If you have VPN access to the NASA network you could try out the Spacebook proof of concept! We are working on the real version now, but when it goes beta we'll invite you.
@Dyadya: Thanks for the recommendation! We'll take a look at it!
@1st Apple Hater: Hostable on GAE means nothing. I have my own server space. Working for a US Government agency means I can't host on GAE. I'll change the blog post to reflect the lack of need for GAE.
@Malcom: NASA as an agency uses RSS as a standard. Yes, RSS has something like 9 variations, but I do not call the shots and hence RSS is a requirement. ATOM support is therefore something that I wouldn't mind doing but is not a requirement.
@Barbara: Thanks for the recommendation!
Actually Byteflow meets your requirements, except ability to integrate easily - it's not a application, it's a project. Though of course you can get only parts you need, I believe that code is pretty good. ;-)
Have you looked at Zine (http://zine.pocoo.org/)?
"So Google App Engine compliant blog systems are right out."
No, they're not. GAE compliant doesn't mean GAE is the only place it'll run.
RSS is an American-centric standard that isn't technically up to snuff either. NASA is American, but the data it collects and houses is not. It's pretty odd for an agency with a lot of globally relevant data wants to use the parochial RSS over Atom.
@Anonymous: Lets just say that I would really, really prefer to publish everything in Atom, but the formal requirement is for RSS.
@Doug Hellmann: I looked at Zine before I got into Django and Pinax. Looks spiffy! However, since I need a Django app that I can plug into Pinax, Zine just won't do. :(
@anon: I'm not sure you could say that RSS 1.0 is an "American standard" particularly since it's RDF (and so is extensible).
Hi,
You might want to consider my own offering, Django Tech Blog. It's pretty close to what you are looking for -- and I could help you get it there!
Will McGugan
Would mightylemon do? It's the code from http://oebfare.com/
@Gert: Since it was created by one of the core-devs of Pinax, I have looked at Oebfare and I like it a lot. I may slurp out pieces of it.
Can Pinax's default blog tool be enhanced to provide what you are missing?
@jocknerd, Normally I would say yes. And it might come to that. The issue though is fitting that into my schedule by formal due dates.
@Will McGugan,
You wrote the Pygame book my son and I have! Awesome!
What did you end up using? We're looking for something similar and the "Easy to integrate into another application" part is killing my search...
Dear Danny
Did you get very far with this?
I am picking a choosing bits to go into a Django-base site. I noticed your CMS call (and I'm now weighing up Django-CMS and FeinCMS).
Did you come to a shortlist for a blog app?
Best wishes
Ivan
Ivan,
If I were to make a stand-alone blog for Django I would go with django-mingus. For something that goes into Pinax, I would choose http://github.com/eldarion/biblion once its ready.
Danny
Thanks for these tip-offs. I'll look them both up.
Sorry I didn't see this before: I hadn't subscribed to comments.
Best
Ivan
Post a Comment